Uncategorized

Freire, Hirsch and Indoctrination: the arguments against, the arguments against

I’ve brought together some arguments against the last post from Twitter and BTL and tried to answer them. The argument about when elitism is elitism and when it’s not….! The argument that people who use elitist academic language to argue against Core Knowledge are themselves elitist, is a common one. Of course that only works,… Continue reading Freire, Hirsch and Indoctrination: the arguments against, the arguments against

Uncategorized

On Freire, Hirsch and indoctrination: falling in love with statues is not always a good idea

In the first line of his epic poem, metamorphosis, the Roman poet Ovid sets the scene for the themes that he intends to cover, in nova fert animus mutatas dicere formas corpora, my mind leads me to tell of forms changed into new bodies, or similar, myth and change is Ovid’s concern. Later, much later,… Continue reading On Freire, Hirsch and indoctrination: falling in love with statues is not always a good idea

Uncategorized

Who breaks a butterfly on a wheel: Kirschner, Sweller and Clarke

I think it is important to say what this is and is not. It is not an advocation of progressive techniques neither is it a refutation of traditional techniques. Rather it is  an attempt to look at the polemics of educational discourse or rather educational blogging discourse. Progressive education is receiving a, some might say,… Continue reading Who breaks a butterfly on a wheel: Kirschner, Sweller and Clarke